Skip to main content
Climate
    • What We Know
    • What Can Be Done
    • Climate Primer
    • Podcast
    • Explainers
    • Climate Questions
    • For Educators
    • News
    • Events
    • Resources
  • Search
Search
MIT

Main navigation

    • What We Know
    • What Can Be Done
    • Climate Primer
    • Podcast
    • Explainers
    • Climate Questions
    • For Educators
    • News
    • Events
    • Resources
  • Search
PostAugust 25, 2020

Responding to the U.S. Energy Secretary's Thoughts on Clean Coal

coal

By Jessica Cohen, Lucy Milde, and Melissa Stok

The U.S. Energy Secretary Dan Brouillette weighed in on the debate over keeping coal mines open during the national emergency with a June opinion piece on PennLive, a news website headquartered near Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. His article covers much more than defining essential businesses during a lockdown, and presents an extremely optimistic view of the future of coal. After thorough research, including interviewing two experts in the field affiliated with MIT, we came to a different conclusion.

Secretary Brouillette is correctly concerned with making our electricity grid emissions-free while maintaining reliability, but overstates coal’s potential. Natural gas plants can be turned on and off more quickly than coal plants, making them more suitable to the needs of grid reliability and providing superior operational flexibility. This is only one of the reasons coal plants are less profitable. Coal has been on the decline since 2011; employment decreased 14% from 2017 to 2019, and plant owners announced the closure of 17 gigawatts by 2025. We are already moving towards more economic and sustainable choices like natural gas and renewables.

Trends in renewable energy are positive: from 2013 to 2018, solar employment grew by 11% annually and in 2018, wind turbine service technician was the second fastest growing occupation in our entire economy. Our government needs to take advantage of these trends instead of investing $100M in Coal FIRST. This program hopes to create “coal plants of the future,” but requires years of development to, at best, reach the air quality and low carbon standards of existing energy sources. In a country that needs economic stimulus, revitalizing former coal communities with renewable energy creates well paying jobs. Secretary Brouilette cites the importance of reliability of coal, but natural gas is more dispatchable than coal, and therefore more profitable as well.

Coal to product, such as producing carbon nanomaterials from coal, could provide jobs through additional manufacturing, but due to the sparse amount of coal actually required to make these products it is extremely unlikely that 47,500 new mining jobs, as Secretary Brouillette suggests, will be created. The value comes from the cutting edge manufacturing- not the coal consumed. Money spent on clean coal, despite the ongoing economic challenges in keeping coal plants open, could be better spent helping communities transition from coal to industries with better prospects.

 

Image credit: Filip Urban, Unsplash

by MIT ESI Rapid Response Group
Topics
Finance & Economics
Energy
Government & Policy

Related Posts

PostNovember 17, 2026

Tariffs, Global Value Chains, and the Incidence of Protection: Evidence fro...

MIT Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research
PostNovember 2, 2026

Powering up for a pivotal moment

MIT Energy Initiative
At the 2026 Energizing@MIT: MITEI’s Annual Research Conference, MITEI principal research scientist Deepjyoti Deka (left) presented his Seed Innovation Fund project on accelerating energy planning in the era of data centers through generative AI.
PostOctober 30, 2026

Study pinpoints states with steepest warming trends since 1980

MIT News
A new study reports global-warming-attributed trends in monthly-averaged maximum daily temperature for every U.S. state. Shown here are temperature changes (highest increases in deeper red and dark orange) between 1991 and 2012 compared to the average temperature between 1901 and 1960.
PostOctober 28, 2026

3 Questions: Why infrastructure is entering a defining era

MIT Civil and Environmental Engineering
“Designing infrastructure is a highly transdisciplinary, sociotechnical endeavor, involving social, technical, and economic considerations. Understanding how these systems are designed is increasingly important because they are becoming more complex, making decision-making particularly difficult,” says Ali Jadbabaie, JR East Professor and head of the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering.

MIT Climate Knowledge in Your Inbox

 
 

MIT Groups Log In

Log In

Footer

  • About
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility
  • Contact
MIT Climate Project
MIT
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • YouTube
  • Simplecast
Communicator Award Winner
Communicator Award Winner