Skip to main content
Climate
    • What We Know
    • What Can Be Done
    • Climate Primer
    • Podcast
    • Explainers
    • Climate Questions
    • For Educators
    • News
    • Events
    • Resources
  • Search
Search
MIT

Main navigation

    • What We Know
    • What Can Be Done
    • Climate Primer
    • Podcast
    • Explainers
    • Climate Questions
    • For Educators
    • News
    • Events
    • Resources
  • Search
PostSeptember 25, 2019

Greener and fairer: Balancing pollution, energy prices, and household income

Traffic in Madrid, Spain

Governments that impose taxes on carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gas emissions can benefit from a cleaner, more climate-friendly environment and a revenue stream that can be tapped to lower other taxes and create jobs. But environmental taxes may also exact an excessive financial burden on low-income households, which spend a much greater fraction of their budgets than richer households do on heating oil, natural gas, and electricity. This concern has limited the use of green taxes in Spain, where emissions are taxed at levels far below average for the European Union, which seeks to lower emissions across the continent to fulfill its 2015 Paris Agreement climate pledge.

Now a new study by researchers at the MIT Joint Program on the Science and Policy of Global Change, the University of Oldenburg in Germany, and the Basque Center for Climate Change in Spain shows that low-income households in Spain can actually benefit from environmental taxes if revenues are redistributed to all taxpayers. Using a computational model to assess the environmental and economic impacts of a green tax reform policy in which revenues are recycled in equal amounts to households in annual lump-sum payments, the researchers found that the policy significantly reduces emissions without imposing economic hardship on any segment of the population. The study appears in the journal Economics of Energy and Environmental Policy.

“There may be a tradeoff between efficiency and equity in climate policy design,” says Xaquin Garcia-Muros, a co-author of the study and postdoctoral associate at the MIT Joint Program. Noting the perfect can be the enemy of the good, as indicated by the November 2018 Yellow Vest protests against fuel tax hikes in France, he adds, “Governments that seek to introduce environmental policies need to show they can cut emissions equitably in order for the public to support them. Otherwise, climate mitigation measures will be rejected by public opinion, and attempts to tackle climate change will be unsuccessful.”

The proposed policy includes a tax on carbon dioxide (CO2) of 40 euros per metric ton in all sectors (except transportation) not covered by the EU emissions trading system, tax increases on fossil fuels to match the EU average of 1.5 percent of GDP, and economy-wide taxes on air pollutants — nitrogen oxides, (NOx) and sulfur dioxide (SO2) emissions at 1,000 euros/metric ton. In addition, it provides annual lump-sum rebates to private households based on household income.

Combining a “computable general equilibrium” model of the Spanish economy with a “micro-simulation” sub-model that characterizes households of different income levels, the researchers determined the tax reform policy’s impact on pollution levels, energy prices, and household net income. They found that the policy would significantly reduce emissions of CO2 (10 percent), NOx (13 percent) and SO2 (20 percent); produce an estimated 7.3 billion euros in annual revenues; and enable annual lump-sum rebates of 400 euros. Most importantly, the rebates would offset the cost of the green taxes for the bottom half of income levels, with the poorest households receiving an average annual net benefit of 203 euros and the richest paying a net cost of 599 euros.

“We expect similar results in other southern European and public transit-oriented countries,” says Garcia-Muros. “But while results will differ for each country, all can benefit by ensuring that green tax policies accommodate economic inequality.” An earlier MIT Joint Program study showed how this principle can be applied in the design of carbon pricing policies in the United States.

by MIT News
Topics
Energy
Climate Justice

Related Posts

PostNovember 17, 2026

Tariffs, Global Value Chains, and the Incidence of Protection: Evidence fro...

MIT Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research
PostNovember 2, 2026

Powering up for a pivotal moment

MIT Energy Initiative
At the 2026 Energizing@MIT: MITEI’s Annual Research Conference, MITEI principal research scientist Deepjyoti Deka (left) presented his Seed Innovation Fund project on accelerating energy planning in the era of data centers through generative AI.
PostOctober 28, 2026

3 Questions: Why infrastructure is entering a defining era

MIT Civil and Environmental Engineering
“Designing infrastructure is a highly transdisciplinary, sociotechnical endeavor, involving social, technical, and economic considerations. Understanding how these systems are designed is increasingly important because they are becoming more complex, making decision-making particularly difficult,” says Ali Jadbabaie, JR East Professor and head of the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering.
PostOctober 26, 2026

At New York Climate Week 2026, MIT connects with a global network

MIT News
Aaron Krol, managing editor of the MIT Climate Change Engagement Program, led MIT’s Climate Week NYC session “Climate Communication for Impact,” which featured (left to right) Allison Crimmons of Talking Climate, Arielle Tannenbaum of Climate Central, and Mallika Talwar of Yale University.

MIT Climate Knowledge in Your Inbox

 
 

MIT Groups Log In

Log In

Footer

  • About
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility
  • Contact
MIT Climate Project
MIT
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • YouTube
  • Simplecast
Communicator Award Winner
Communicator Award Winner